I
ask DR. BRUNVAND, “The textbook that we’re using in our class, The Study of
American Folklore, is probably the most widely used textbook, certainly for
folklore, that I’ve been able to find when I talked to other folklore
instructors. It’s sort of what they’re
using.”
DR.
JAN HAROLD BRUNVAND responds: “Well I'm pleased
with it. I tell how I started that. Well,
first, remember the book is organized by categories, or genres of folklore. I mentioned Dorson’s
book, which is organized in terms of American history and American development.
So it went from colonial to native folk
humor and Negro slavery, and I forgot, folk heroes, modern folklore, regional
folklore, immigrant folklore, and so on.
It’s more culturally or regionally or topically organized where as mine –“
Roesch
interrupts, “Oral customary material.”
DR.
JAN HAROLD BRUNVAND: “Well, Dorson didn’t do anything with -- you mean mine?”
Roesch: “Yes.”
DR.
JAN HAROLD BRUNVAND: “Yeah, Dorson didn’t do anything with customary material to speak
of, but I decided to do it by genres of folklore after just three chapters on general
things. The oral categories: being things like folk speech proverbs,
riddles, rhymes, legends, tales, myths, and so on. You know the customary: starting with superstitions and customs and
gestures and so on. And then, material
culture, which was a fairly new aspect of folklore study in 1968 when I wrote
that. Now, I don’t know everything about
all of this, for example, music, I’m not trained in or don’t -- I don’t read music. I'm not, you know, musically adept at all. I know how to run my CD player but -- and I
know it -- I know something about music but I’m not able to write that without
doing
research,
same thing with dance. And so I tried
very hard to rely on the authorities or rely on the experts and to bring as
much in it as I could from the numerous publications. And the big job in doing a textbook is the bibliography.
Once you get that for each chapter, then
you just have to select some examples and so on. The actual background of the book -- goes back
to Dorson again.
I think my whole life rotates around this man, who I just so luckily
took in the classroom when I was an undergraduate. When I was a graduate student in
Well, although I’m sure his motive went deeper
than that. So I outlined it and I wrote
the chapter on proverbs. First draft,
the chapter on proverbs, because I had that lecture. And by the time they had reviewed it and sent
it to me, I was at Southern Illinois at Edwardsville where I stayed for one
year, and I get a letter from them saying we’d like to publish it and here’s
the contract, and we can talk about how long it will take you to write it and
so on. And I was really
flabbergasted. I said, what am I going to do when I get to music and dance, or how will I
-- one of the ideas I got was to have sample studies at the end and I got Henry
Glassie to write that classic essay on the Southern
mountain log cabins. And he was just
getting to be known in folklore. He’s
now just a really big name in folk art.
We dropped those in the latest editions but they were there for a long
time. And I took the contract to the
chair of my department and said, is there anything I should know that I don’t
know? And he said, well, you ought to
ask him for a little more -- a little higher percentage on the sales, a little
bigger advance and there were couple other points. And I say, can I -- I’m not that
well-known. I mean, can I really be -- well,
you can always ask. And they agreed to everything. Well, I did most it, of the writing and later,
I had to do some revising. But most of the original writing (happened) in the basement of the
house we were renting in
With
the subject matter chapters, they can bring in their own examples and just ask if
the students had questions or responses and then bring in their own examples of
a legends or proverbs or superstitions.
But they were kind of stock with these essays. So we decided to put these examples Of -- I think it was three per chapter isn't it?
Roesch: Right.
DR.
JAN HAROLD BRUNVAND: “-- examples and
study questions. And what those are, are
the things I’ve been using in class for years.”
Roesch: I see, yeah.
DR.
JAN HAROLD BRUNVAND: “Those are my
examples, but they are the sort of things that any good folklore teacher can
compile from some of his or her own experiences or student’s collections or
things you clip. I find so much in the
media that I clip out, advice columns I read religiously and comic strips and
interviews and so on. So I didn’t have
any trouble coming up with these -- what do they call it? You call them focus boxes.
Roesch: Focus box.
DR.
JAN HAROLD BRUNVAND: And then the little
study questions, and it was really fun to work those up. "Get your docks in a row", what does
that come from? or "it ain’t over until the fat
lady sings" and how that’s been used.
I love using the gestures, because I have so many nice pictures clipped
from the media of famous people, particularly presidents doing -- Nixon with
his famous triple V sign and Reagan making a little circle with his finger in shaking,
the way of doing this--
Roesch: Oh yeah.
DR.
JAN HAROLD BRUNVAND: I’m just fine
looking out on the hospital window. And
so on. So we did change the book
somewhat in that way.
Roesch:
“And I think those are good changes. I’ve been using the book since your 3rd
edition for a short time with the appendixes and now, the 4th edition, and I
think that’s -- there’s been some good changes.”
DR.
JAN HAROLD BRUNVAND: Well, I like them
--
Roesch: The new photographs --
DR.
JAN HAROLD BRUNVAND: I liked them, but the
last folklore meeting where I spoke was about a month ago. And the man introducing me said something about
how the textbook had been so useful to him and then he turned, looked at me,
and said, but I like the 3rd edition better.
And the paper I was giving there had to do with nostalgia in relation to
an item of folk art I was discussing. So
I just look back at him said, well, you’re just overly nostalgic about it. Have to change your attitude. But it’s been very interesting. There’s a book of readings that goes with it
that has declined in sales, people didn’t pick it up quite as quickly as they did
the textbook and perhaps I should redo that.
There’s, of course, a lot of new stuff published every year in folklore
and papers and meetings and so on. There are other textbooks, but I think mine
has succeeded with undergraduate and introductory courses, because -- it’s -- well,
for one thing, teachers can teach it any order they want. They don’t have to start with chapter 1 and work
their way through. And the examples are a
sort of student tested for decades in my classes – If something doesn’t work, I change it or drop it and try something else.
Roesch: It also has an excellent bibliography as you
go on.
DR.
JAN HAROLD BRUNVAND: Boy,
that was a struggle to get all that together.
Roesch: And an excellent index.
DR.
JAN HAROLD BRUNVAND: Yeah, I didn’t, I
can’t take responsibilities for that.
Roesch: Somebody did that?
DR.
JAN HAROLD BRUNVAND: Yeah, I tried to index
a book once and decided it was -- you know they deduct it from your royalties
if they’re paying someone to index it and I decided it was worth it to have it
done right.