Response Papers

Home
Up

Purpose and Content
Your purpose is to present your reactions to the texts that we have been studying. 

Feel free to express your opinions about the readings and the texts we have studied.  What do the works make you think of?  What do they remind you of?  Why?  Do you agree or disagree with the authors?  Feel free to make connections between one text and another, between the text and your lived experiences, between the text and what you have heard, read, or seen in other classes or in other contexts.  As much as possible in two pages, you should develop a full yet concise response to your reading. 

Each of the four response papers should discuss your reactions to one or more works from the periods listed below:

Response Paper # 1: Antiquity through the Renaissance 
Response Paper # 2: 17th and 18th Centuries 
Response Paper # 3: 19th Century
Response Paper # 4: 20th Century 


The Technical Parameters 
Please follow these guidelines: 

  1. Each response must fill at least 2 pages (and no more than 3), typed, double-spaced, using one of the following fonts:
    • Courier New, size 12
    • Bookman, size 12
    • Arial, size 12
  2. The page layout must follow MLA guidelines.  Review the sample on p. 715 of the Holt Handbook.  For your convenience, you may use the template for MLA Style.
  3. Your opening sentence must somehow identify the writers and the works that your paper discusses.
  4. All material that is borrowed from any text—whether quoted, paraphrased, or summarized—must be documented appropriately following MLA guidelines. Use parenthetical references rather than footnotes or end notes.
  5. You must include a "Work Cited" page.  It's a good habit to get into!


Grading Criteria 
Because the purpose of this assignment is to get you to articulate your thoughts and your reactions to the reading, your papers will be graded as follows. 

A. Excellent—You have articulated a deep, thoughtful response.  You have analyzed what the author says; you have made connections between texts; and you have made connections beyond the texts.  (Making "connections beyond the text" means that you have recognized connections between the text and your lived experiences; or between the text and what you have heard, read, or seen in other classes or in other contexts.)
B. Good—You have articulated a thoughtful response.  You have analyzed what the author says, and you have made connections between texts.  (Making "connections between texts" means that you have engaged in some comparing and contrasting of two or more selections from our textbook.)
C. OK—You have written a so-so response.  You have analyzed or summarized a work or two from our text, but you haven't made any connections between the two or beyond the text. 
F. Unacceptable—You have forgotten to cite the text and/or any other source that you discuss!
Those are the basic grading criteria.  In addition to those, be aware that errors in grammar and mechanics will lower your score by one grade or more, depending on the severity of the distractions

 

 

Home ] Up ]

Last modified: August 19, 2003